Products – Muddy's Bake Shop

Online orders need at least 2 days' notice. Need something quick? Walk-in or call during open hours!

Please note:

+ Pickups are available during open hours (Wed-Sat).

+ In-store menu is usually the same as preorder menu, however items marked "sold out" online may be in stock in the shop. Full size cakes are sold in the shop, but in limited flavors & quantities.

+ Need it sooner than 2 days out? Or further than 4 weeks? Contact us to see what's available!

Birthday Bash- Decorated Cake

Birthday Bash- Decorated Cake

Regular price From $40.00

Regular price Sale price From $40.00
Unit price per
Birthday Bash- Decorated Cupcakes

Birthday Bash- Decorated Cupcakes

Regular price From $25.50

Regular price Sale price From $25.50
Unit price per
Birthday Candles

Birthday Candles

Regular price $5.00

Regular price Sale price $5.00
Unit price per
Blueberry Cake: June & July Special

Blueberry Cake: June & July Special

Regular price From $46.00

Regular price Sale price From $46.00
Unit price per
Blueberry Cupcakes: June & July Special

Blueberry Cupcakes: June & July Special

Regular price From $25.50

Regular price Sale price From $25.50
Unit price per
Brown Butter Crispy Rice Treats

Brown Butter Crispy Rice Treats

Regular price From $7.95

Regular price Sale price From $7.95
Unit price per
Buttercream Blessings - Decorated Cake

Buttercream Blessings - Decorated Cake

Regular price From $65.00

Regular price Sale price From $65.00
Unit price per
Cherry Basket - Decorated Cake

Cherry Basket - Decorated Cake

Regular price From $45.00

Regular price Sale price From $45.00
Unit price per
Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars

Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars

Regular price From $7.95

Regular price Sale price From $7.95
Unit price per
Classic Cake

Classic Cake

Regular price From $37.00

Regular price Sale price From $37.00
Unit price per
Classic Cupcakes

Classic Cupcakes

Regular price From $21.50

Regular price Sale price From $21.50
Unit price per
Cocoa Crackle Pie

Cocoa Crackle Pie

Regular price $27.00

Regular price Sale price $27.00
Unit price per
Cookie & Cupcake Decorating Party Package

Cookie & Cupcake Decorating Party Package

Regular price $0.01

Regular price Sale price $0.01
Unit price per
Deluxe Chocolate Chip Cookies

Deluxe Chocolate Chip Cookies

Regular price From $7.95

Regular price Sale price From $7.95
Unit price per
Dino Party- Decorated Cake

Dino Party- Decorated Cake

Regular price From $55.00

Regular price Sale price From $55.00
Unit price per
Double Chocolate Brownies

Double Chocolate Brownies

Regular price From $14.50

Regular price Sale price From $14.50
Unit price per
Family Favorites Cookie Platter

Family Favorites Cookie Platter

Regular price $45.00

Regular price Sale price $45.00
Unit price per
Festive Sprankle Toppings

Festive Sprankle Toppings

Regular price $0.01

Regular price Sale price $0.01
Unit price per
Gender Reveal- Decorated Cake

Gender Reveal- Decorated Cake

Regular price From $50.00

Regular price Sale price From $50.00
Unit price per
Gingerbread Molasses Cookies

Gingerbread Molasses Cookies

Regular price From $7.95

Regular price Sale price From $7.95
Unit price per
Grasshopper Cake

Grasshopper Cake

Regular price From $37.00

Regular price Sale price From $37.00
Unit price per
Grasshopper Cupcakes

Grasshopper Cupcakes

Regular price From $21.50

Regular price Sale price From $21.50
Unit price per
Kapow! - Decorated Cake

Kapow! - Decorated Cake

Regular price From $45.00

Regular price Sale price From $45.00
Unit price per
Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie

Regular price $30.00

Regular price Sale price $30.00
Unit price per
Lemon Zinger Cake

Lemon Zinger Cake

Regular price From $39.00

Regular price Sale price From $39.00
Unit price per
Lemon Zinger Cupcakes

Lemon Zinger Cupcakes

Regular price From $21.50

Regular price Sale price From $21.50
Unit price per
Mini Cake

Mini Cake

Regular price From $25.00

Regular price Sale price From $25.00
Unit price per
Mini Cupcakes

Mini Cupcakes

Regular price $18.00

Regular price Sale price $18.00
Unit price per
Mod Daisies- Decorated Cake

Mod Daisies- Decorated Cake

Regular price From $40.00

Regular price Sale price From $40.00
Unit price per
Mod Daisies- Decorated Cupcakes

Mod Daisies- Decorated Cupcakes

Regular price From $25.50

Regular price Sale price From $25.50
Unit price per
Mom's Spiced Tea Mix

Mom's Spiced Tea Mix

Regular price $11.75

Regular price Sale price $11.75
Unit price per
Muddy's Baking Mixes

Muddy's Baking Mixes

Regular price From $10.00

Regular price Sale price From $10.00
Unit price per
Muddy's Drinkware

Muddy's Drinkware

Regular price $25.00

Regular price Sale price $25.00
Unit price per
Muddy's Gift Card

Muddy's Gift Card

Regular price From $10.00

Regular price Sale price From $10.00
Unit price per
Nancy's Boy Pie

Nancy's Boy Pie

Regular price $30.00

Regular price Sale price $30.00
Unit price per
Oatmeal Cream Pies

Oatmeal Cream Pies

Regular price From $11.75

Regular price Sale price From $11.75
Unit price per
Peachy Keen Pie

Peachy Keen Pie

Regular price $35.00

Regular price Sale price $35.00
Unit price per
Plain Jane Cake

Plain Jane Cake

Regular price From $37.00

Regular price Sale price From $37.00
Unit price per
Plain Jane Cupcakes

Plain Jane Cupcakes

Regular price From $21.50

Regular price Sale price From $21.50
Unit price per
Private Group Baking Class (in-person or virtual)

Private Group Baking Class (in-person or virtual)

Regular price $0.01

Regular price Sale price $0.01
Unit price per
Private Group Business Skills Class

Private Group Business Skills Class

Regular price $0.01

Regular price Sale price $0.01
Unit price per
Prozac Cake

Prozac Cake

Regular price From $37.00

Regular price Sale price From $37.00
Unit price per
Prozac Cupcakes

Prozac Cupcakes

Regular price From $21.50

Regular price Sale price From $21.50
Unit price per
Rainbow Revelry- Decorated Cake

Rainbow Revelry- Decorated Cake

Regular price From $40.00

Regular price Sale price From $40.00
Unit price per
Rainbow Revelry- Decorated Cupcakes

Rainbow Revelry- Decorated Cupcakes

Regular price From $27.00

Regular price Sale price From $27.00
Unit price per
Rainbow Sprankle Cookies

Rainbow Sprankle Cookies

Regular price From $7.95

Regular price Sale price From $7.95
Unit price per
Red Velvet Cake : July Special

Red Velvet Cake : July Special

Regular price From $39.00

Regular price Sale price From $39.00
Unit price per
Red Velvet Cupcakes: July Special

Red Velvet Cupcakes: July Special

Regular price From $21.50

Regular price Sale price From $21.50
Unit price per
Rosettes All Over- Decorated Cake

Rosettes All Over- Decorated Cake

Regular price From $35.00

Regular price Sale price From $35.00
Unit price per
Savory Snackers

Savory Snackers

Regular price $7.95

Regular price Sale price $7.95
Unit price per
Seasonal Pie of the Month Subscription

Seasonal Pie of the Month Subscription

Regular price From $85.00

Regular price Sale price From $85.00
Unit price per
Shady Wake Pie

Shady Wake Pie

Regular price $35.00

Regular price Sale price $35.00
Unit price per
Signature Sheet Cake

Signature Sheet Cake

Regular price From $85.00

Regular price Sale price From $85.00
Unit price per
Signature Swirl- Tiered Cake

Signature Swirl- Tiered Cake

Regular price From $165.00

Regular price Sale price From $165.00
Unit price per
Southern Chess Pie

Southern Chess Pie

Regular price $27.00

Regular price Sale price $27.00
Unit price per
Strawberry Fields Forever Cake

Strawberry Fields Forever Cake

Regular price From $39.00

Regular price Sale price From $39.00
Unit price per
Strawberry Fields Forever Cupcakes

Strawberry Fields Forever Cupcakes

Regular price From $21.50

Regular price Sale price From $21.50
Unit price per
Sunrise Flower Burst - Decorated Cake

Sunrise Flower Burst - Decorated Cake

Regular price From $45.00

Regular price Sale price From $45.00
Unit price per
Sweet Repeat Sheet Cake

Sweet Repeat Sheet Cake

Regular price From $105.00

Regular price Sale price From $105.00
Unit price per
Swiss Dot Multicolor- Decorated Cake

Swiss Dot Multicolor- Decorated Cake

Regular price From $40.00

Regular price Sale price From $40.00
Unit price per